Welcome Guest [Log In] [Register]
http://s1.zetaboards.com/Gundam_Eclipse/index/

Welcome to Gundam Eclipse. We hope you enjoy your visit.


You're currently viewing our forum as a guest. This means you are limited to certain areas of the board and there are some features you can't use. If you join our community, you'll be able to access member-only sections, and use many member-only features such as customizing your profile, sending personal messages, and voting in polls. Registration is simple, fast, and completely free.


Join our community!


If you're already a member please log in to your account to access all of our features:

Username:   Password:
Add Reply
Help with finding a new PC
Topic Started: May 12 2018, 11:27 PM (160 Views)
LeDelmo
Member
I am looking for some advice/recommendations with my search for a new PC. I know this probably isn't the first place you would go. But, I am sure there are more than just a few knowledgeable people on here on this subject. And I don't know where else to ask.

I haven't bought-en myself a nice PC in a long time. And I think I am long over do for one.

So I have been thinking about what kind of PC would I want? Allot of stuff has changed. So there is allot to learn.
I was between the ideas of building a nice compact PC or buy a nice laptop.

I like the idea of the laptop that way I could easily take it wherever I want.

But, I am pretty stubborn... I want the Laptop to be VR comparable, a large battery (75whrs or higher), No G-sync on the screen (for better battery life), 100hz panel or higher, the ability to run the graphics off the CPU instead of the GPU when the GPU isn't necessary, and compatible with external GPU's (at a later date I will buy and dedicated monitor for the laptop for home use and a external GPU for it as-well).

So far the laptops I have found are the Gigabyte Aero, Razer Blade, and Alienware. I like MSi's and Asus's computers aswell but finding a model that meets my needs for them seem really hard. Especially the Asus because they seem to love G-Sync so much. Leaving you with laptops that get 2-3 hours of use...(that's not even gaming!)

Screen sizes between 13-15"


I know building a custom compact would be cheaper. But, I really don't know by how much. As prices are still really high because of those Cryptocurrency miners.

Anyways looking forward to hearing you alls thoughts on the matter. Feel free to make you own recommendations as-well.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
kajnrig
Fan
Prices are higher not just because of the cryptocurrency boom (which seems to be on a downward trend), but also because of insanely high DRAM prices. There's actually a lawsuit in the works alleging price fixing on the part of the three main DRAM manufacturers, Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron. (A claim bolstered by Micron's claim to... investors?... some years back that they were no longer looking to maximize market share but rather to maximize profit.)

Anyway, I wouldn't be able to help you much with regards to laptops. Some of your wants do seem a bit... untenable, though. A high refresh rate monitor on a gaming laptop that doesn't have G-Sync/Freesync included is highly unlikely to exist. To even get 100+ FPS on a modern game, you'll need a higher-tier internal graphics card, which makes an external video card redundant. Heck, the internal card might very well BE a desktop card on some laptops.

I'd say get the laptop for now, see how you like it, then when you get the home monitor, test the laptop on it and see how you like that. If it just won't do, then get/build a desktop tailored to your needs.

EDIT:

What a coincidence, this just popped up on my Youtube feed:

Edited by kajnrig, May 13 2018, 09:30 AM.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
LeDelmo
Member
The MSI G65 Stealth is definitely interesting. I hear mixed reviews about it though. So, it was surprising it was number 1 on their list. But, I really do like that one. Seems to meet most of my needs like the other three on my list. But, it's still behind the others in battery life.

The Alienware 15 R4, Razer Blade, and Gigabyte Aero 15X. Still seems to be the best options ATM.

But, I also found out something interesting as-well. Apparently, external GPU's run differently depending on how they are used. I am not sure if its the laptop hardware or the way the manufacturers design the External GPU's themselves.

But the Razer Blade with its external Razer Core V2 offers very little benefit. Compared to just running to its internal GPU.
Best Desktop Graphics for your Laptop
Where as the Alienware offered substantial benefits. (I would only want to run a external GPU for a external monitor)

So, I am wondering if its something I need to watch out for in the laptop or if it just depending on the External GPU you get.
Jeez, even small desktops are just as expensive.

I like MSI's Compacts like the Trident 3 White and Vortex G25. But, Both those are between $1,500-$2,000 by themselves.

I also looked into building a custom one. I like the Lazer3D LZ7 case. But, again I think it would still be around that $1,500 mark.

Edited by LeDelmo, May 13 2018, 10:01 PM.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
WarMachine395
Member Avatar


Apparently cryptominers really only hold 6% of the market share in GPUs with that being heavily biased towards AMD cards specifically. On the whole the situation is a bit weird and I suspect that manufacturers may be pushing the numbers a bit in their favour. That all said GPU prices are currently dropping and will continue to do so with the next generation of cards coming this summer.

I actually work as a custom PC builder, so I'm a little biased in favour of towers over laptops, I just believe a tower will last you longer both in quality and performance. I will say the laptops you've listed off are pretty good ones from what I have seen and heard, so I don't think you can really go wrong there. Though maybe I would avoid the Alienware myself.

May I ask what you need the PC to be able to do, I may have some advice based on that.
https://twitter.com/WarMachine395/status/916395301673431042

Here's my rig too, its a bit on the flashy side admittedly. It is a
Spoiler: click to toggle


I was actually thinking about swapping to a Black InWin 101c:
https://www.in-win.com/en/gaming-chassis/101c
Edited by WarMachine395, May 13 2018, 10:50 PM.

Facebook-----Youtube-----Blogspot
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
LeDelmo
Member
My main requirement will be VR compatibility. I do game but haven't on a PC is a long time. So I don't know exactly what kind of demand that would take just yet. But, the VR compatibility requirement should be enough power to run most games I would think.

Ideally, I would like to see frames at or above 120fps at 1080p. But, I am lenient on that for laptops. (however, having the faster screens is nice still to have the extra head room)

If I do go desktop, I would want a fairly small footprint. Something that could be easily moved around if need be.

And if I am being truthful the laptops are concerning me a little. The life expectancy on these things is terrible. And replacement batteries seem to be out of the question now. As it seems manufacturers do not offer replacement parts anymore.
Also thanks for the recommendation to those InWin cases. Some of them look really good.
Edited by LeDelmo, May 13 2018, 11:13 PM.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
kajnrig
Fan
You can cram a full-size desktop into a small space, but you'll pay a premium for the compact size. You'll want to look at Micro-ATX and Mini-ITX form factors for both the motherboard and case.

Something like the Fractal Design Node 202 (https://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16811352059) would be a good place to start as far as the case goes. It's small enough that you can easily move it around, but also has enough space inside to fit all your essential components. Its shape is also such that you can set it horizontally or vertically however you see fit (so long as ventilation is unencumbered).

I'm with WarMachine in that I'm partial to DIY desktop builds, but there's no denying the convenience of a laptop, so it's really up to you to decide what your priorities are. Keep us up to date, though. If you do decide on a desktop build, I'd love to help with that... and maybe live vicariously. :D
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
WarMachine395
Member Avatar


LeDelmo
May 13 2018, 11:07 PM
My main requirement will be VR compatibility. I do game but haven't on a PC is a long time. So I don't know exactly what kind of demand that would take just yet. But, the VR compatibility requirement should be enough power to run most games I would think.
You're not wrong to do VR right you do need some pretty solid hardware.
1500 Canadian rupees is probably what you are looking at price wise.

Quote:
 
You can cram a full-size desktop into a small space, but you'll pay a premium for the compact size.
Yep, usually the smaller parts come at a premium and at a loss in performance and features too.
I'll leave this here too, its about the size of a shoebox and can actually fit a full size graphics card
http://www.phanteks.com/Enthoo-Evolv-Shift.html
Edited by WarMachine395, May 14 2018, 07:03 AM.

Facebook-----Youtube-----Blogspot
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
kajnrig
Fan
WarMachine395
May 14 2018, 07:01 AM
I'll leave this here too, its about the size of a shoebox and can actually fit a full size graphics card
http://www.phanteks.com/Enthoo-Evolv-Shift.html
I looked at that on Newegg a couple weeks ago and couldn't tell which side was up, down, front, back, what went where and where the outputs were and how you were supposed to access them...
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
WarMachine395
Member Avatar


kajnrig
May 14 2018, 08:57 AM
WarMachine395
May 14 2018, 07:01 AM
I'll leave this here too, its about the size of a shoebox and can actually fit a full size graphics card
http://www.phanteks.com/Enthoo-Evolv-Shift.html
I looked at that on Newegg a couple weeks ago and couldn't tell which side was up, down, front, back, what went where and where the outputs were and how you were supposed to access them...
Its a bit weird, it's really intended as an home theatre PC case so they've actually gone out of their way to conceal all of the IO. Essentially all the IO is coming out the "top" and then is routed out a hole in the back.

Again it is very weird as PC cases go

Facebook-----Youtube-----Blogspot
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
LeDelmo
Member
So, I wanted to get an idea of cost to build a custom mini ITX. And this is what I came up with.

CASE:
Lazer3D LZ7 $200

MOTHERBOARD:
Asus Strix Z370-i $200

CPU:
Intel i7 8700k $400

GPU:
GTX 1080 $600

RAM:
G.SKILL TridentZ series/RGB model 16Gb x1 $200? (I cant find just 1 stick but 2x16Gb is $400)
(I am also thinking right around the 3333mhz would be a good speed)

MEMORY:
2x 512Gb M.2 cards $300 (Would only run with M.2 no other HDD or SSD will be used.)

POWER:
HDPlex $100

OS:
Windows 10 $100

COOLER:
(I have allot of options here)
Noctua NH-L9 $40
Noctua NH-L12S $50
Reeven RC-1001b $36
Cryorig M9i $20

Now I am not sure if I got everything I need. As I am not sure what my fan situation would be. But, I think that would cover almost everything if I am not mistaken.

All together looks like it would cost around $2,150. Granted I was just rounding. But, I just wanted this as a general idea of cost.

What you think. Does this look about right? Any thoughts?
Edited by LeDelmo, May 14 2018, 04:49 PM.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
WarMachine395
Member Avatar


8700k are really hot so you need to be very careful with the coolers, I'm wondering as well if you are intending to OC? :D

I'd avoid the L9 for this config it just doesn't have the TDP for it: https://noctua.at/en/nh_l9i_tdp_guidelines

The L12S is probably a good choice but you would probably need to get low profile memory to fit it together as the Trident Z stuff is very tall and quite fat with its heat spreaders (95W) EDIT This might fit not super sure it is 66mm tall so I think it may be very tight if it does. https://noctua.at/en/nh-l12/specification

I think the Cryorig M9i is probably the best choice as best I can tell it shouldn't obstruct anything and it has the highest TDP out of all of them (120W) EDIT too tall didn't notice how the PSU fit in

And you will definitely want a 600W PSU minimum, so maybe something like this: https://www.newegg.ca/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16817139155&gclid=EAIaIQobChMImJ785pOG2wIVxouzCh3ycwoYEAAYASAAEgK-jPD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds
CPU cooler clearance is only 67mm!
https://www.lazer3d.com/product/lz7/
Edited by WarMachine395, May 14 2018, 05:52 PM.

Facebook-----Youtube-----Blogspot
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
LeDelmo
Member
I really wanted to avoid using such a large PSU internally. I know you can make external ones but I also want to avoid it looking too janky.

Your probably right about the processor as-well. I didn't think about that. I don't really need to have a K chip anyways. A normal 8700 would probably be just fine. I am thinking about over-clocking to at-least 4-4.5ghz.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
WarMachine395
Member Avatar


^You need the k series chip and a Z board to OC

Facebook-----Youtube-----Blogspot
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
kajnrig
Fan
LeDelmo
http://gundameclipse.net/single/?p=913051&t=8284723

CASE:
Lazer3D LZ7 $200

Really tight case. I'd be careful about space and thermals. The 8700K runs hot, so overclocking is almost assuredly out of the question.

Quote:
 
CPU:
Intel i7 8700k $400

Not a bad choice, but again I'd be concerned about keeping it sufficiently cool in a case as tiny as this.

Quote:
 
RAM:
G.SKILL TridentZ series/RGB model 16Gb x1 $200? (I cant find just 1 stick but 2x16Gb is $400)
(I am also thinking right around the 3333mhz would be a good speed)

Intel chips aren't as dependent on high-speed RAM as AMD chips. You can save a good chunk of change dropping down to 2400MHz without losing any significant gaming performance. You can also split the 16GB into 2x8GB... unless you're adamant about having 16GB sticks. The 2x8GB will have the benefit of running in dual-channel mode as opposed to the single-channel of the 1x16 (which isn't that important for Intel chips, again, but in certain tasks it makes a difference).

Quote:
 
MEMORY:
2x 512Gb M.2 cards $300 (Would only run with M.2 no other HDD or SSD will be used.)

Make sure the drive is SATA or PCI-E (NVMe) as supported by your motherboard. M.2 is a form factor, not a standard, so you can have M.2 drives that read/write at slower SATA III speeds or the faster speeds of a PCI-E interface.

Quote:
 
OS:
Windows 10 $100

I'm no advocate, but there are sites that sell apparently legit Windows keys for extremely cheap. I wouldn't know how/where to get them and/or the veracity of such keys, but even the big, reputable tech channels have dabbled with them. Food for thought.

Anyway, take WarMachine's advice as well. Big things to look for are cooling for that 8700K (look for TDP numbers for air coolers and/or radiator size for AIO water coolers if you decide to go that route, the higher the better) and a power supply to handle everything (the 600W suggested is a good minimum, I'd recommend 850W if you intend to overclock, want a quieter system, or even just for redundancy's sake).

Edit:

I was gonna recommend the 8700 actually, if you didn't absolutely need the overclock. You'll still need a good cooler for it, but you won't suffer as much.
Edited by kajnrig, May 14 2018, 06:50 PM.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
LeDelmo
Member
Ah, never mind read it wrong. I'm not sure if the 8700k would be worth it for just the over-clocking though. Especially, if the 8700 can do 98% of what the 8700k can. Only the 8700 can run cooler and use less power.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
WarMachine395
Member Avatar


LeDelmo
May 14 2018, 06:51 PM
Ah, never mind read it wrong. I'm not sure if the 8700k would be worth it for just the over-clocking though. Especially, if the 8700 can do 98% of what the 8700k can. Only the 8700 can run cooler and use less power.
That's a tricky question. In all honesty the 8700k would probably thermal throttle down to the same specs as an 8700 anyways. The 8700 still runs very hot and it comes with a stock cooler that is kind of crappy that no one should ever really use as it is exceedingly noisy :D

If you wanted to forgo the OC you could actually save a little more money by moving down to an H370 board as well: https://www.pcworld.com/article/3268063/components-processors/intel-motherboard-z370-vs-h370-vs-b360-vs-h310-8th-gen-cpu.html

Here's the H370-I, it has a very similar feature set minus the OC functionality: https://www.asus.com/ca-en/Motherboards/ROG-STRIX-H370-I-GAMING/




Facebook-----Youtube-----Blogspot
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
LeDelmo
Member
: / even going with the normal 8700 and H370 board. I'd only save about $150. BUT, if I go with a 1060 instead of the 1080, That would save at-least $350 there alone.

So option 2 would be
i7 8700
H370
GTX 1060

So that saves about $500. Which still makes this a $1,650 build.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
kajnrig
Fan
WarMachine395
http://gundameclipse.net/single/?p=913060&t=8284723
The 8700 still runs very hot and it comes with a stock cooler that is kind of crappy that no one should ever really use as it is exceedingly noisy :D
Not only noisy, it also just flat-out fails at its job. The 8700 has an all-core turbo frequency of 4.3 GHz, but the box cooler will only be able to maintain 4.2 GHz... at a CPU temperature of 100 degrees Celsius... in a decently cool room.

You'll always be able to maintain a speed above the base clock of 3.2 GHz with the stock cooler, but you definitely WON'T be able to maximize its performance.

LeDelmo
http://gundameclipse.net/single/?p=913061&t=8284723
: / even going with the normal 8700 and H370 board. I'd only save about $150. BUT, if I go with a 1060 instead of the 1080, That would save at-least $350 there alone.


A 1060 or AMD RX 480/580 are solid choices all around, but they'll have trouble hitting 120 fps on some games, to say nothing of maintaining it.

EDIT:

GPU prices are steadily coming back down to MSRP, so that's something else to keep in mind if you're not in urgent need.
Edited by kajnrig, May 14 2018, 09:41 PM.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
WarMachine395
Member Avatar


You could always build and run the system without the graphics card until the prices come down or the next gen cards launch :D

I would suggest the GTX 1060 6Gb if you can wrangle one at a good price, honestly Nvidia just makes a better optimized card for gaming than AMD does.

Facebook-----Youtube-----Blogspot
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
kajnrig
Fan
WarMachine395
http://gundameclipse.net/single/?p=913064&t=8284723
I would suggest the GTX 1060 6Gb if you can wrangle one at a good price, honestly Nvidia just makes a better optimized card for gaming than AMD does.


Oh, and to add to this, make certain it's a 6GB (that's six gigabytes) card and NOT a 3GB (three gigabytes) card, as the latter actually has fewer compute units (ie a weaker chip with less raw compute strength) in addition to less VRAM. (For comparison's sake, the RX 480 8GB and RX 480 4GB are identical in every way except for the amount of VRAM.)
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
WarMachine395
Member Avatar


So this is a very very long post I figured a couple variations on the system we're talking about and an equivalent or better performing AMD system


i7-8700


OR

Core i7+-8700 with Optane Storage Module


OR

This actually works surprisingly well for a small scale build because the 2700 only throws 65 Watts, and the cooler is still enough to OC it a bit :D
Ryzen 7 2700


kajnrig
May 14 2018, 10:36 PM
Oh, and to add to this, make certain it's a 6GB (that's six gigabytes) card and NOT a 3GB (three gigabytes) card, as the latter actually has fewer compute units (ie a weaker chip with less raw compute strength) in addition to less VRAM. (For comparison's sake, the RX 480 8GB and RX 480 4GB are identical in every way except for the amount of VRAM.)
There was one card that AMD made that was misleading in that exact same way as well though I can't really remember which model (I think it may have been the 560 maybe)
Edited by WarMachine395, May 14 2018, 10:43 PM.

Facebook-----Youtube-----Blogspot
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
LeDelmo
Member
It seems like no matter what you do. Small form Custom desktop, Pre-built small form desktop, Mid size tower desktop, Or even a Laptop. They all seem to be around the same price range ($1,500 to $2,200) with similar specs.

Though, the GTX 1080's seem to be a rare and very expensive luxury.

I don't think I will go with AMD though. That's a whole other ordeal all together.
Offline Profile Quote Post Goto Top
 
1 user reading this topic (1 Guest and 0 Anonymous)
« Previous Topic · Entertainment · Next Topic »
Add Reply

Powered by web analytics software.